Penn State’s Stunning Decision: The Dismissal of James Franklin
A Rocky Season Begins
In a move that sent shockwaves through the college football world, Penn State University announced the firing of head coach James Franklin just six games into his 12th season. The announcement was made by the university on a dreary Sunday, reflecting a season that has slipped into chaos following a heartbreaking three-game losing streak. Once ranked as the No. 2 team in the preseason AP Top 25, the Nittany Lions find themselves in a precarious position, currently 0-3 in Big Ten play after a shocking home loss to Northwestern.
Unprecedented Upset and Consequences
The home defeat against Northwestern, where the Nittany Lions were favored by a staggering three touchdowns, exemplified the downward spiral of a once-promising season. This astonishing upset marked the second consecutive defeat for Franklin’s squad, following a loss to previously winless UCLA. It is a notable statistic that Penn State has now become the first FBS team since 1978 to suffer back-to-back losses as favorites of at least 20 points.
The Interim Leadership Takes Charge
With the departure of Franklin, the university has appointed associate head coach Terry Smith as the interim coach for the remainder of the season. Smith, who also serves as the cornerbacks coach, faces the daunting task of revitalizing a season that has derailed rapidly. The hope is that he can provide a spark and redirect the team’s efforts during this turbulent time.
A Legacy of Achievements
"Penn State owes an enormous amount of gratitude to Coach Franklin who rebuilt our football program into a national power," stated athletic director Patrick Kraft in the official announcement. Franklin’s tenure was marked by significant achievements: he won a Big Ten Championship, led the team to seven New Year’s Six bowl games, and even steered the Nittany Lions to a College Football Playoff appearance just last year. However, Kraft emphasized the need for new leadership as the program strives for greater heights.
A Dismal Stretch of Games
Franklin’s departure is particularly poignant given the promise this season held. The Nittany Lions had begun the 2025 campaign by winning their first three games, buoyed by veteran talent at key positions. However, the season flipped dramatically, exposing serious flaws within the team. Penn State’s initial success gave way to a series of difficult losses, including a double-overtime defeat against Oregon in their Big Ten opener, a game marked by Franklin’s persistent struggles against top-ranked opponents.
The High Cost of Firing Franklin
Navigating Franklin’s dismissal raises significant financial implications for Penn State. His latest contract, worth around $8 million annually through 2031, includes a buyout of approximately $50 million, making it one of the largest in college football history. This financial burden raises questions about the university’s priorities and future investments in their athletic programs.
The Timeline of Downfall
The timeline of Penn State’s swift decline this season is telling. It began promisingly but quickly turned into a nightmare:
-
Sept. 27: The team suffered an emotional double-overtime loss against No. 6 Oregon, failing to capitalize on a late-game rally.
-
Oct. 4: In an upset of epic proportions, Penn State fell to a winless UCLA team, marking their first loss to an 0-4 team since 1985.
- Oct. 11: Hosting Northwestern, the Nittany Lions once again faltered, losing a game they were expected to win handily.
With a record now standing at 3-3, Franklin’s tenure reflected a stark contrast to previous seasons where consistent performances led to multiple appearances in bowl games and a strong standing in the Big Ten.
Patterns of Big-Game Failures
While this season serves as a lightning rod for criticism, Franklin’s struggles in high-pressure games have been a persistent concern throughout his career. His record against top-ranked teams paints a grim picture: a win percentage of .160 against highly ranked opponents, coupled with a stark 2-21 record against top-6 teams. This ongoing struggle to win the big game combined with the inability to capitalize on high expectations ultimately contributed to the administration’s decision to move forward without him.
Future Prospects and Coaching Candidates
As the Nittany Lions search for their next head coach, several potential candidates are already making headlines. Names like Matt Rhule and Curt Cignetti are being floated among fans and analysts alike as deserving successors who can invigorate a program that once held national promise. Given the depth of talent within the existing roster, the next coaching hire becomes not just a pivotal decision but also a chance for the university to reclaim its status among the elite in college football.
Penn State’s firing of James Franklin is more than just a coaching change; it is a pivotal moment that will define the program’s trajectory for years to come. As players, fans, and alumni grapple with this transition, the search for a new leader will be closely watched and critically examined. The spotlight now shifts to the interim leadership of Terry Smith and the future coaching search, with hopes high for a turnaround that restores Penn State to its former glory.
